The key challenge of PSInSAR(Permanent Scatter Interferometric Synthetic Aperture Radar)lies in the quality of Permanent Scatter(PS)points, which are difficult to extract accurately in fracture zones due to the complex natural ground cover and unique geomorphological environments. In such areas, the inability to reliably extract high-quality PS points limits the application of PSInSAR for monitoring interseismic deformation. To address the problem of high-quality PS point selection in fault zones and improve the effectiveness of PSInSAR technology for monitoring interseismic deformation, this paper presents a comparative study of coherence coefficient and amplitude deviation double thresholds. The study further integrates the Kolmogorov-Smirnov(KS)test and CR homogeneous pixel method, in addition to conventional coherence coefficient point selection techniques. Sentinel-1A SAR images from March 14, 2015, to February 16, 2020, are used as the data source, with the Wushan-Gangu section of the fault zone on the northern edge of the Western Qinling Mountains, near the northeastern edge of the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau, serving as the test area for PSInSAR processing. The quality and reliability of PS point selection using various methods are compared and analyzed.
Two sets of coherence coefficient Tγ and amplitude deviation Dγ double thresholds were tested. The coherence coefficient was set at Tγ=0.5, while the amplitude deviation Dγ was set to 0.5 and 0.3, resulting in 19806 and 2485 PS points, respectively. When the amplitude deviation threshold was lowered, the number of PS points on ridgelines decreased significantly, while there was little change in Gangu County, suggesting poor pixel amplitude stability in mountainous areas. Lowering the threshold eliminated many PS points, retaining only those with high amplitude and stable time series, typically found in hard targets like urban buildings. A KS double sample test was then applied in combination with the double threshold method, with all thresholds coefficient Tγ, amplitude deviation Dγ, and KS test Pγ set at 0.5. This approach yielded 1 313 PS points, showing a significant reduction in PS points on ridgelines and in Gangu County, while urban points became more concentrated on hard targets like buildings. Although the KS test reduced PS points in vegetated areas, it did not fully eliminate noise points. Finally, based on the double threshold results of coherence coefficient Tγ=0.5 and amplitude deviation Dγ=0.3, both the KS test and CR homogeneous pixel selection methods were applied. The CR homogeneous pixel method used a phase difference threshold Pγ=0.5 and a temporal phase stability threshold Nγ=50. This yielded 2 485 PS points for the double threshold method, 133 PS points for the double threshold plus KS test, and 414 PS points for the double threshold plus CR homogeneous pixel method. The latter two methods significantly reduced PS points, with a higher concentration of points in Gangu County, consistent with the expectation that PS points predominantly correspond to hard targets like buildings.
Statistical analysis of the results demonstrated that the combination of the coherence coefficient, amplitude deviation, and CR homogeneous pixel method provided the highest quality PS points, effectively excluding noise points in vegetated areas. The combination of coherence coefficient, amplitude deviation, and KS test ranked second, improving accuracy in urban areas but failing to eliminate noise in vegetated areas. Using Sentinel-1A SAR images and the Wushan-Gangu fault as the test area for time series PSInSAR processing, the accuracy of PS point selection was further verified. A comparative analysis of deformation monitoring results from the three methods revealed that both the KS test and CR homogeneous pixel method improved the accuracy of fault deformation monitoring, with the CR homogeneous pixel method yielding superior results. Monitoring data from 2015 to 2020 showed that the deformation rate of the northern block of the Wushan-Gangu fault ranged from -2 to -0.2mm/a, with an average deformation of approximately -1.7mm/a. In contrast, the southern block exhibited a deformation rate between 0.3 and 0.5mm/a, with an average deformation of about 1.8mm/a The relative average deformation rate between the northern and southern blocks was 0.7mm/a, indicating left-lateral strike-slip movement. Among the three methods, the double threshold plus CR homogeneous pixel method produced PS points with the smallest deformation rate standard deviation, indicating more stable and reliable deformation results.
With the recent development of geodetic observation theory, the increasing satellite platforms and the progress of related technology, InSAR is emerging as a new data source and useful tool for remotely-based geodetic observations. More importantly, InSAR observations play an increasingly irreplaceable role in the field of coseismic deformation observations, earthquake emergency responses, earthquake hazard evaluation and seismogenic structure research. Particularly, InSAR is the most commonly used tool in coseismic deformation measurements on the Qinghai-Tibetan plateau or other global seismic zones, where GPS data are sparse or inaccessible in some cases. Specifically, InSAR measurements help us to respond in time after disastrous earthquakes and provide valuable information associated with how the surface of the crust deforms due to large earthquakes. In the area of scientific research, InSAR provides products of surface deformation observations and serves as model constraints kinematically or dynamically in identifying the buried faults, studying the characteristics of seismogenic faults, obtaining three-dimensional displacements, and investigating the relationship between earthquakes and tectonic structures. InSAR observations and its deformation products have the technical advantages of large spatial scale, high precision and in-time, compared to other geodetic measurements. Consequently, InSAR has the ability to provide scientific and technological support for earthquake emergency observations, and meeting the practical needs of earthquake disaster reduction on the Qinghai-Tibetan plateau.
In this review, we mostly limit our focus to the application of InSAR technology in earthquake cycle deformation monitoring in different structural settings on the Qinghai-Tibetan plateau. We also summarize the InSAR-based studies on fault kinematics and seismogenic structures related to some noted earthquakes on the Qinghai-Tibetan plateau. We highlight how the applications of InSAR data can greatly promote earthquake science and can be used as routine observations in some important areas. Then proceed to discuss the cutting-edge development trend and some new challenges of InSAR technology, which are frequently discussed and investigated, but not well resolved, in recent applications. The endeavors in increasing the precision of small-magnitude deformation measurements and expanding the InSAR data volumes can make the scientific objectives of earthquake disaster reduction on the Qinghai-Tibetan plateau and its surrounding areas feasible and reliable. To better understand how InSAR observations have changed the way we study earthquakes, we summarize the development, commercialization, insights, and existing challenges associated with InSAR coseismic deformation measurements and application in recent two decades.
The reliability of anomaly extracting methods is crucial for pre-seismic thermal anomalies research. However, there is a lack of relevant researches. We compared two commonly used anomaly extracting methods, Z-score(ZS)and Robust satellite technology(RST)method, taking the 2014 Yutian earthquake as a typical example and the 2008 Wenchuan earthquake as a validation. The four aspects of extracted results are compared qualitatively and quantitatively, including the extraction effect, sensitivity to slight change, suppression of background information and indication of seismic information in the actual earthquake case. Moreover, the extracted results of validation case are used to validate the reliability of typical case results. Many intermittent anomalies in surface temperature and outgoing longwave radiation appeared before Yutian earthquake. The frequency of anomalies increases with the proximity of earthquake. The spatial distribution of surface temperature and outgoing longwave radiation anomalies gradually concentrated around the fault zone at the same time. The largest surface temperature and outgoing longwave radiation anomalies occurred one month before Yutian earthquake. The difference between the extraction results of ZS and RST method is mainly manifested in the frequency and amplitude of anomaly changes. The frequency and amplitude of anomaly changes obtained by RST method are higher than those obtained by ZS method. To further explore the reason for these differences, we further evaluate the two methods quantitatively by combining the data of two non-seismic years before and after Yutian earthquake respectively. The sensitivity of anomaly extraction method represents its ability to identify the slight changes of thermal parameters caused by the seismogenic process. The two methods are sensitive to slight changes, but the RST method is better than ZS method. The background information represents normal variation in surface temperature and outgoing longwave radiation caused by non-seismic factors. Suppression of background information determines the accuracy of extraction results. The comparison results show that both methods have certain suppression effect to background information, but the ZS method is better. The spatial distribution of pre-seismic thermal anomalies is an important index for predicting earthquake information(e.g. time of occurrence and location of epicenter). The results of quantitative comparison through normalized distance index show that for surface temperature data, ZS method is slightly better than RST method in indicating the location of epicenter. However, RST method is better for outgoing longwave radiation data. The maximum value of normalized distance index of ZS method occurred closer to the origin time of earthquake. We used the same quantitative evaluation method for the validation earthquake case. The verification results show that in addition to the sensitivity to anomaly changes, the comparison results of the two earthquake examples are similar in terms of the ability to suppress background information and indicate earthquake information. The difference is that ZS method has a better ability to suppress background information and RST method is better in indicating earthquake epicenter in the verification earthquake example. The main reason for the difference in extraction effect between the two methods is that the RST method averages the ground feature classification, and the difference between the observed value and the average value of the classification makes the RST method have a certain amplification effect on the weak signal. The difference between the typical earthquake case and the verification earthquake case is mainly due to the different complexity of the object types in the regions. Based on the above research results, we believe that ZS method and RST method have certain ability to extract pre-seismic anomalies. However, comparatively speaking, the RST method also has a good effect on the extraction of anomalies caused by other factors, and there is uncertainty in the ground feature classification. We believe that ZS method is a more appropriate and simple anomaly extraction method in the general seismic anomaly change extraction.
The seismogenic fault of the Maduo MS7.4 earthquake in Qinghai Province on May 22, 2021 is not on the conventionally north boundary of the Bayan Har Block, but a secondary fault named Kunlunshankou-Jiangcuo Fault inside the Bayan Har Block which is nearly parallel to the East Kunlun Fault, with a distance of about 70km. As a result, the study on the stress effect of the Maduo earthquake on surrounding faults is urgent, especially on the main boundary faults of the Bayan Har Block, such as the East Kunlun Fault. In this paper, the lithospheric structure of the study area is stratified by using the USTClitho1.0 results of the unified seismic velocity model of the lithosphere in Chinese mainland. The co-seismic slip model of the Maduo earthquake is inversed by the results of InSAR deformation field and precise aftershock location. The model reveals that the coseismic slip of this earthquake is mainly sinistral strike-slip, the fault strike is 276 degrees, the dip angle is 80 degrees, the average rake angle is 4 degrees, the maximum slip is about 5.1m, and the main slip area is mainly concentrated on the depth of 0~15km. By considering the Burgers rheological model which is more consistent with the actual deformation process of lithosphere, the paper calculates the co-seismic Coulomb stresses and viscoelastic Coulomb stresses in the source area and peripheral faults induced by the Maduo earthquake by using PSGRN/PSCMP program.The results show that, besides the fracture surface of the seismogenic fault, there are three positive co-seismic Coulomb stress change areas on the west and east ends of the seismogenic fault, of which the stress loading area on the west end is oriented toward the northwest of the seismogenic fault, and the other two stress loading areas on the east end are toward the north and east of the seismogenic fault. The positive section of co-seismic Coulomb stress change of the peripheral faults is consistent with the distribution of the source area. The co-seismic Coulomb stress change induced by Maduo earthquake is bigger than 0.01MPa on the near source section of East Kunlun Fault, the east section of Kunzhong Fault, the northwest segment of Gande-Nanyuan Fault and the middle segment of Wudaoliang-Changshagongma Fault. The maximum co-seismic Coulomb stress changes at the depth of 12.5km reach 0.165MPa, 0.022MPa, 0.102MPa and 0.012MPa, respectively, which proves that the Maduo MS7.4 earthquake has a strong seismic triggering effect on the above faults. By comparison, the impact of Maduo MS7.4 on co-seismic Coulomb stress change is also positive in the middle section of Longriba Fault, the south section of Xianshuihe Fault and the north section of Longmenshan Fault, but the magnitude is relatively smaller(less than 0.01MPa), in which the co-seismic Coulomb stress change in the middle section of Longriba Fault increases by thousands of Pa, while the co-seismic Coulomb stress change in the south section of Xianshuihe Fault and the north section of Longmenshan Fault increases by only tens to hundreds of Pa.For the fault sections with co-seismic Coulomb stress change bigger than 0.01MPa mentioned above, their viscoelastic Coulomb stress changes during 50 years are calculated. The results show that the viscoelastic relaxation of lithosphere after the Maduo earthquake further increases the viscoelastic Coulomb stress changes on the above faults, especially the East Kunlun Fault, where the cumulative Coulomb stress will be increased by 0.038MPa after 50 years. The seismic triggering effect of Maduo earthquake on the above faults will continue to increase over time and more attention should be paid to the seismic risk of the above faults in the future.
We achieved the coseismic displacements of the Napa MW6.1 earthquake located in California US occurring on 24 August 2014 by using InSAR data from the newly launched ESA's Sentinel-1A satellite. The 30m×30m ASTER GDEM was used to remove the terrain effect, and phase unwrapping method of branch-cut algorithm was adopted. In order to obtain a better coseismic displacement field, we also tested 90m×90m SRTM data to remove the terrain effect and Minimum Cost Flow algorithm to unwrap the phase. Results showed that the earthquake caused a significant ground displacement with maximum uplift and subsidence of 0.1m and -0.09m in the satellite light of sight(LOS). Based on the Sentinel-1A dataset and sensitivity based iterative fitting(SBIF) method of restrictive least-squares algorithm, we obtained coseismic fault slip distribution and part of the earthquake source parameters. Inversion results show that the strike angle is 341.3°, the dip angle is 80°, rupture is given right-lateral fault, average rake angle is -176.38°, and the maximum slip is ~0.8m at a depth of 4.43km. The accumulative seismic moment is up to 1.6×1018N·m, equivalent to a magnitude of MW6.14.
Earthquake prediction is one of the key areas of earthquake research. Thermal infrared abnormity, which is the abnormally increased land surface temperature, is universal before earthquake and has complex nonlinear relation with the three elements of earthquake. Combining the advantage of neural network, this paper provides a method for earthquake prediction by taking thermal anomaly as information source and constructing a neural network to carry out the test. Based on the MODIS data which has synthesis of eight days with 1km resolution, taking a 10°×10° rectangle, whose center is the epicenter, as research area, and a two-month time before earthquake as the time range, we used RST algorithm to extract thermal anomaly information before earthquake. Considering the time-space relationship between thermal anomaly information and the fault zone, thinking carefully about the information of the neural network input neurons, we constructed BP neural network and used 100 earthquake cases with magnitudes larger than 5, and 70 random samples without earthquake in the research region for training and simulating. According to the statistical analysis, the prediction accuracy is 80%, missing prediction rate is 20%, and false prediction rate is 13.3%. Prediction accuracy of magnitude with error within magnitudes of 2 is 69%, prediction accuracy of earthquake origin time with error within 30 days is 87.5%, and prediction accuracy of epicenter location with error within 3°is 81.2%. The result shows that BP neural network-based earthquake prediction is feasible by using thermal infrared abnormal precursor extracted by RST method. However, in this experiment, the determination of the start time of thermal abnormity, the origin point and range of research area are based on the known epicenter location and time. In fact, the result depicts a non-linear relationship between earthquake and thermal abnormity, and the accuracy of prediction reflects the correlation degree. Therefore, the prediction accuracy of future earthquake may be not as large as our result. For future earthquake prediction, accurate selection of research area and neuron number of hidden layer in neural network has great influence on prediction result.
The variance component estimation method (VCEM) in generalized surveying adjustment theory, which realizes optimal weights allocation for different data sources, is applied to jointly invert two independent datasets, InSAR and GPS, for 3-D deformation field acquisition in this paper. Illustrated by the case of the Wenchuan earthquake, 3-D deformation field in high coherent area near the fault is achieved by using this method, which shows clearly a whole picture for the locations of right-lateral and thrust components movements generated by the earthquake. The 3-D deformation results are quantitatively consistent with GPS observations with RMS errors less than 5cm in 3-D directions, which demonstrates the feasibility to acquire precise 3-D deformation field by employing VCEM to fuse independent deformation datasets.
Consisting of three water diversion projects, i.e. Western Route Project(WRP), Middle Route Project(MRP)and Eastern Route Project(ERP), South-to-North Water Diversion Project is by far the world's largest water conservancy project. It is also a major strategic infrastructure to optimize the allocation of water resources in China. The MRP has a total length of 1267km, including a canal segment of 731km long located in Henan Province, which accounts for more than half of the total mileage and runs through from north to south the central plains of China. The project starts mainly in the north of Henan Province, running through Hebi mining area(i.e. Hebi Coal Industry Group Co. Ltd.), Tangyin graben, three cities(i.e. Weihui, Hebi and Anyang city)and two counties(i.e. Qixian county and Tangyin county). Being threatened by mining subsidence, regional tectonic activities and urban groundwater subsidence, its embankment is prone to instability. In order to assess the stability of embankment along the route, and also to provide safety guarantee for the water diversion project, with the case of the north Henan section of Middle Route Project(MRP), all 9 periods of ENVISAT ASAR data of 2009 are processed by means of 2 PASS plus external DEM D-InSAR processing algorithm, the parameters of space-time baseline are analyzed, best optimal interferometry images pairs are selected, and D-InSAR processing strategies are optimized to obtain differential interferograms for 33 monitoring points along 127km route; information of subsidence area, urban surface settlement area, as well as the amplitudes due to groundwater mining is extracted, and thematic maps of interferometric phase change vectors are gotten. The following understandings are obtained: 1)There is uneven subsidence over the diversion canal. The cumulative minimum amount of subsidence is -33mm, and maximum subsidence is -73mm in 350 days. Annual subsidence rate is between 0.34m/yr to 0.76m/yr, and annual average subsidence rate is 0.53m/yr. In general, subsidence of monitoring points fits with exponential distribution, with the average correlation coefficient R2=0.7418. According to some mathematical models of curve fitting for monitoring point subsidence, it can be predicted that the subsidence of embankment of water diversion canal tends to be stable in majority of the sections. At the same time, both subsidence value and rate are getting smaller. 2)This study shows that due to combined effect from a variety of factors, this region has a poor regional geological stability. Analysis reveals that tectonic activity and urban surface subsidence are the main influencing factors, infrastructure construction is the secondary effect on the embankment stability, and there is no direct correlation with mining subsidence.
In the past few years, the improved InSAR technology based on time series analyses to many SAR images has been used for measurement of interseismic deformation along active fault. In the paper, we first made a summary and introduction to the basic principle and technical characteristics of existing Time Series InSAR methods(such as Stacking, PSInSAR, SBAS). Then we presented a case study on the central segment of Haiyuan Fault in west China. We attempt to use the PS-InSAR(Permanent Scatter InSAR)technique to estimate the motion rate fields of this fault. We processed and analyzed 17 scenes of ENVISAT/ASAR images in descending orbits from 2003-2010 using the PS-InSAR method. The results reveal the whole movement pattern around the Haiyuan Fault and a remarkable velocity gradient of about 5mm/a across the central segment of the fault. The motion scenes are consistent with left-lateral strike-slip. On this basis, we make a discussion on some issues about observation of fault activity using Time Series InSAR methods, such as the changes of LOS deformation rates with fault strike and region width observed across a fault, fault reciprocity and motion style indicated by Time Series InSAR rate map and the relationship between the InSAR LOS deformation and the ones from other methods. All these studies will benefit the promotion of InSAR application in detection of tectonic movement.
Vertical coseisimic deformation near seismogenic fault is one of the most important parameters for understanding the fault behavior, especially for thrust or normal fault, since near field vertical deformation provides meaningful information for understanding the rupture characteristics of the seismogenic fault and focal mechanism. Taking Wenchuan thrust earthquake for an example, we interpolate GPS horizontal observed deformation using Biharmonic spline interpolation and derive them into east-westward or north-southward deformation field. We first use reliable GPS observed value to correct InSAR reference point and unify both GPS and InSAR coordinate frame. We then make a profile using InSAR data and compare it to that from GPS data and we find GPS and InSAR observation reference point has a 9.93cm difference in the hanging wall side, and around -11.49cm in the footwall. After correction, we obtain a continuous vertical deformation field of the Wenchuan earthquake by combined calculation of GPS and InSAR LOS deformation field. The results show that the vertical deformation of both hanging wall and foot wall of the fault decreases rapidly, with deformation greater than 30cm within 50km across the fault zone. The uneven distribution of the vertical deformation has some peak values at near fault, mainly distributed at the southern section(the town of Yingxiu), the middle(Beichuan)and the northern end(Qingchuan)of the seismogenic fault. These three segments have their own characteristics. The southern section of the fault has an obvious asymmetric feature, which exhibits dramatic uplift reaching 550cm on the hanging wall, with the maximum uplift area located in Yingxiu town to Lianshanping. The middle section shows a strong anti-symmetric feature, with one side uplifting and the other subsiding. The largest uplifting of the southern segment reaches around 255cm, located at the east of Chaping, and the largest subsiding is in Yongqing, reaching around -215cm. The vertical deformation of the northern section is relatively small and distributed symmetrically mainly in the north of Qingchuan, with the maximum uplift to be 120cm, locating in the northernmost of the seismogenic fault.
The distribution and characteristic of ground deformation is a key issue in geodesy,which brings insight into the geometry of the ruptured fault and seismic hazard assessment in the future in the surrounding areas. It also provides better constraint conditions for geophysical inversion. Compared with field research,satellite imagery regularly provides detailed and spatially comprehensive images and is a most valuable alternative especially for the study in remote areas. So,observing seismic rupture is urgent after earthquake. InSAR is useful for measuring ground displacement,but the technique has severe limitations that are mainly due to data decorrelation and signal saturation,and it does not generally provide measurements in the near-fault area where large displacements occur. In this paper,the sub-pixel correlation method and SPOT image are used to map the Wenchuan earthquake rupture and to identify the faults activated by the earthquake. A computation is introduced of the inverse projection matrices for which a rigorous resampling is proposed. Image registration and correlation is achieved with an iterative unbiased processor that estimates the phase plane in the Fourier domain for subpixel shift detection,then the earthquake deformation field is derived.The results indicate that the Wenchuan earthquake produced at least surface ruptures on two faults along the Longmenshan Fault,the main rupture named Beichuan-Yinxiu rupture zone(Longmenshan town-Gaochuan in this map)and the secondary rupture named Hanwang rupture zone.The former is characterized by dextral-slip thrusting with a horizontal displacement of 4~6m in average and a dextral-slip displacement of 1~3m near Gaochuan town.The latter is characterized by pure thrusting,with horizontal displacement 1~2m in average. There is no obvious ground rupture along Wenchuan-Maoxian Fault.The research indicates that sub-pixel correlation using optical image can be a powerful complement to differential radar interferometry,which can measure ground displacement near the fault zone.The study also shows that earthquake displacement fields can be calculated by remote sensing technology.The surface rupture can be traced and the meizoseismal area can be located by this method. Compared with field research,satellite imagery regularly provides detailed and spatially comprehensive images and is a most valuable alternative especially for the study in remote areas.
The interferometric baseline is a vital parameter in the InSAR technique,which determines the correlation between two repeat-pass images and imposes direct effect on the accuracy and reliability of the mapping result. If the baseline is not accurately estimated,the residual phases from the orbit and topography will be left in the expected phase of deformation leading to errors of the final result. In this work,we analyze the influences of the baseline on the reference phase and simulated topography phase,and present several methods of interferometric baseline estimation. Then we study the mapping process of the coseismic and post-seismic deformation of the 1997 Mani,Tibet M7.7 earthquake based on the 8-sence ERS2-SAR data and InSAR.Our attention is focused on comparison of interferograms under varied conditions for baseline estimations,such as rough orbit data,precise orbit data,frequency of interferometric fringes and control points on the ground. The result shows that when the baseline is estimated by rough orbit data,the yielded differential interferograms contain considerable phases of orbit residuals which make fringes dense and deformation enlarged. Thus we must use the precise orbit data for baseline estimation. Sometimes,however,the influence of the orbit cannot be removed completely even if we employ precise orbit data. In this case we should make further corrections,including removing superfluous fringes based on interferometric fringes frequency and baseline correction using the control points on the ground. With these improvements,the resultant coseismic displacement along the fault of the Mani earthquake is 4.5m. The post-seismic deformation by this event is concentrated in a narrow 10~20km-long zone around the fault. The accumulated fault slip 508 days after the main shock reaches at least 5.6m,which continues to grow with time. These analysis results are consistent with the field observations,meaning the improvement method presented in this paper is effective.
Because the seismic data is so various and is continuously increasing in number,sharing seismic data and providing data service is more difficult.This paper proposes a method to optimize the existing seismic data model based on the modeling tool of PowerDesigner.The method was initially applied to the exiting 1/4000000 active fault GIS database.Aimed at the actual problem of active fault GIS database,the method realizes the optimization of fault data model.And the optimized fault database was applied to specific example cases.Meanwhile,comparative analysis was done between the optimized PDM with the old one.The result shows that the optimized model is more flexible and convenient to use,the data description is more accurate,the relationship between data is clearer,and the data constraint is more standard and complete. It can meet the different needs of seismologists.The proposed optimization method for earthquake data model has a certain value of popularization and application,and it lays a good foundation for seismic data sharing and data service in the future.