SEISMOLOGY AND GEOLOGY ›› 2019, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (6): 1429-1443.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.0253-4967.2019.06.008

• Research Paper • Previous Articles     Next Articles

INFLUENCE OF PUMPING ON FOUR-COMPONENT BOREHOLE STRAIN AT TAI'AN SEISMIC STATION AND ITS INTERFERENCE MECHANISM

JIA Yuan1, GAN Wei-jun2, LI Jie1, ZHU Cheng-lin1,2, YIN Hai-tao1, LU Shuang-ling1, JU Jia-bin3   

  1. 1 Shandong Earthquake Agency, Jinan 250014, China;
    2 State Key Laboratory of Earthquake Dynamics, Institute of Geology, China Earthquake Administration, Beijing 100029, China;
    3 Tonghua Seismic Station of Jilin Province, Tonghua 134000, China
  • Received:2019-01-31 Revised:2019-05-05 Online:2019-12-20 Published:2020-03-10

抽水对泰安地震台钻孔分量应变的影响及其机制

贾媛1, 甘卫军2, 李杰1, 朱成林1,2, 殷海涛1, 卢双苓1, 鞠佳斌3   

  1. 1 山东省地震局, 济南 250014;
    2 中国地震局地质研究所, 地震动力学国家重点实验室, 北京 100029;
    3 吉林省通化地震台, 通化 134000
  • 通讯作者: 甘卫军,研究员,E-mail:wjgan@gps.gov.cn
  • 作者简介:贾媛,女,1984年生,工程师,2009年于武汉大学测绘学院获大地测量学与测量工程专业硕士学位,现主要从事形变数据分析研究工作,E-mail:jiayuan84@126.com。
  • 基金资助:
    山东省自然科学基金(ZR2017LD009)、山东省重点研发计划项目(2018GSF120007)和山东省地震局科研基金(JJ1606Y)共同资助

Abstract: Four-component borehole strainmeter (FCBS) is one kind of high-precision borehole strain observation instruments invented in China. As a kind of near-surface deformation observation instrument, FCBS is also easily disturbed by the external environment factors. As a common factor, pumping has significant influence on FCBS observation. Existing studies mostly identify the pumping interference from the perspective of observation curve morphology, relatively few studies focus on its interference mechanism. In order to truly capture earthquake precursor information, it is necessary to study the interference mechanism. In recent years, RZB-3 type FCBS at Tai'an seismic station has been seriously affected by pumping, so it is necessary and also feasible to study the interference mechanism of pumping. Since the influence of pumping interference on borehole strainmeter is common, this work would be very practical and be used for reference by other borehole strain observation stations.
We find that the original observation curves and observed surface strain, shear strain from RZB-3 type FCBS at Tai'an seismic station have the characteristics of synchronous change with the borehole water level, in which the linear correlation coefficient between the two observed shear strain curves and borehole water level reached 0.70 and 0.82 respectively. We further find that the principal strain direction of borehole and borehole water level after normalization meet the nonlinear function as y=1.217arctan(x)0.224-0.284. The above phenomenon indicates that the observation of RZB-3 type FCBS at Tai'an seismic station is significantly affected by the borehole water level, and the influence is more obvious and the gradient is larger at the stage of low water level. Pumping interference often appears in low water level stage and changes the rock pore pressure state. Statistics show that pumping interference affects the borehole strain state.
To investigate the interference mechanism of pumping to RZB-3 type FCBS at Tai'an seismic station, we take a known pumping as an example, in which we study the principal strain state of the borehole in three periods of normal pumping, interruption of pumping and resuming pumping respectively. During each period, we solve 3 parameters of the principal plane strain state, i.e. the maximum principal strain rate, the minimum principal strain rate and the maximum principal strain direction from four observation equations of FCBS by nonlinear iterative least squares algorithm. On the other hand, concentrated load model (CLM) is used to simulate the mechanical mechanism of pumping. Firstly, the depth of FCBS relative to pumping source and the concentrated load at pumping source are inversed, then, the strain state surrounding the pumping well, including the state at RZB-3 borehole, is simulated by forward modeling. By comparing these results, we find that:
(1)The concentrated load at pumping source inversed by CLM during periods of normal pumping and resuming pumping are both located at or near the bottom of the pumping well, which is consistent with the actual situation, indicating that mechanism and degree of the influence of pumping on borehole strain are well simulated by CLM.
(2)The observed strain state is consistent with the simulation result of pumping interference by forward modeling, indicating that the principal strain state of borehole calculated based on observation of FCBS reflects the true strain state of borehole under different pumping states.(3)The inversed concentrated load at pumping source during pumping periods is significant greater than the load of the pumped water, indicating that the pumping process has more significant influence on the pore pressure of rocks than the load of the pumped water.
Even though CLM is an approximate simulation since it's based on some elastic assumptions, the interference mechanism of pumping on RZB-3 type FCBS at Tai'an seismic station is well explained, which is maybe very helpful for studying the influence of pumping interference on other deformation instruments, locating the unknown pumping source and studying the characteristics of pore pressure of rocks.

Key words: borehole component strain, pumping interference, strain state, concentrated load model, interference mechanism, pore pressure

摘要: 抽水干扰在钻孔应变观测中常见且影响显著,为了捕捉到真实的地震前兆信息,必须对其干扰机制进行研究。统计结果表明,近年来泰安台RZB-3钻孔分量应变受抽水干扰严重。对此,文中以一个现场查明抽水信息的抽水干扰为例,分正常抽水、中断抽水和恢复抽水3个时段计算了钻孔的主应变状态,并利用集中载荷模型反演了应变仪相对抽水源集中力的深度和集中力,在此基础上正演模拟计算了抽水干扰对周边区域的影响。结果表明:1)反演的抽水源集中力位于抽水井底部及其下方附近,与实际情况吻合,模型较好地模拟了抽水干扰对钻孔应变的影响机制和程度;2)钻孔分量应变观测的应变状态与抽水干扰模型正演结果较为一致,根据观测结果计算的钻孔主应变反映了不同抽水状态下钻孔的应变状态;3)反演的抽水源集中力与所抽出的水量载荷相比,抽水过程对岩石孔隙压力的影响要显著得多。

关键词: 钻孔分量应变, 抽水干扰, 应变状态, 集中载荷模型, 干扰机制, 孔隙压力

CLC Number: